By now, those who follow Guantanamo-related news closely are aware of today’s censorship episode during the military commission hearing for Khalid Sheikh Mohammed (KSM).
During military commission hearings, journalists and observers are seated outside of the courtroom. They can watch the hearings as they happen, but the sound is delivered via an audiovisual feed, which has customarily had about a 60-second delay.
Today, however, an unknown government censor abruptly shut off the audiovisual feed as David Nevin, counsel to KSM, began his request for information on the case, igniting frustration in the courtroom. Until today, no one, including Judge Pohl and the defense attorneys, knew that the feed could be cut off by someone outside of the courtroom. The feed is usually cut off by a security officer in the court or the judge, and typically everyone in the courtroom is aware of what is happening.
The action today generated a buzz on twitter amongst journalists present at the hearing. Charlie Savage (@Charlie_Savage) said that the switch was hit after the attorney simply read the title of his own, unclassified brief. Many others, like John Knefel (@johnknefel) indicated the surprise of Judge Pohl, and were surprised to find that even Judge Pohl didn’t know who hit the censorship switch. Knefel tweeted,
“Let today’s censorship episode sink in. Gov official cut feed. When it returned, judge was furious & confused abt why it happened.”
It is rumored that the censorship issue will be addressed at a press conference in the morning, but until then, it certainly brings to light some interesting questions about the secrecy surrounding Guantanamo.
Who is really in control of the courtroom, if its not Judge Pohl? Why did the government feel the need to censor Nevins’ opening statements? As it turns out, there is even more secrecy surrounding Guantanamo than even those who appear to be closest to the action could imagine.
Kelly Ann Taddonio, Research Fellow
Center for Policy & Research